"We were on the roof on Monday, young Lisiek and I and we saw the Herr Kommandant come out of the house on the patio right there below us and he drew his gun and shot a woman who was passing by. Just a woman with a bundle, just shot her through the throat. She was just a woman on her way somewhere, she was no faster or slower or fatter or thinner than anyone else and I couldn't guess what had she done. The more you see of the Herr Kommandant the more you see there are no set rules you can live by, you cannot say to yourself, 'If I follow these rules, I will be safe.'"
This quote, from one of the most powerful scenes in the movie 'Schindler's List', portrays the powerlessness of living in an environment without rhyme or reason. Whether one does what they are told or not, follows the advice of those in power or not, it makes no difference. Obviously we are not living in a concentration camp, but our society none-the-less increasingly resembles the same inescapable powerlessness, even if in a much more diluted and subtle form.
I recognize I've said many times before the universe is a place governed by randomness, though within the bounds of the laws of physics. Nature has no more regard for Planet Earth in general or human beings in particular than it does for other planets or species. But humans were randomly "selected" to "receive" a sense of justice. Our cultures are ultimately a collective recognition that only together can we maximize everyone's odds in the face of an indifferent world that is as likely to sooner or later deliver a natural disaster to our doorstep as it is a bumper crop at harvest time. In short, we understand the virtues of cooperation and fairness, even if often we fail to apply them.
So I feel a bit peeved (understatement) at our increasing failure to apply justice - to allow injustice to persist in our relations with each other even in the face of collective exposure to an uncaring universe. Most societies are content with the minimum amount of cooperation and mutual regard necessary to get by and still, hopefully, hold themselves together. A dangerous game as leaders of the Middle East are learning today and the recent riots in London foreshadow.
Given what's going on in my own life I take it all a bit personally. I've applied for countless jobs, am seeking housing in a world that increasingly demands proof of employment before they'll rent to you, and generally seems hell bent on making sure you don't get a fresh start. If society says it rewards hard work, education, and encourages risk taking in the interest of fostering innovation and both personal and collective advancement, then it should actually deliver. People in such a society, if the rhetoric is be believed, shouldn't lose their shirt if things don't go according to plan. Paying a price for taking a risk and failing is one thing. Losing everything is another.
Chris and I haven't done everything right. Who ever does? But we've done more right than wrong. Unfortunately, there is not enough work and what work there is fails to cover the bills. In the absence of steady income housing is harder to come by, leaving us without a place from which to sell some of our excess stuff as planned. Student loans don't come close to covering all the costs associated with getting an education, especially if you're an older non-traditional student, and most of the scholarships out there are small, tend to be random drawings or essay contests (both time consuming and highly competitive) often targeting young students fresh out of high school. Being in Canada, at least we don't have the added disadvantage of having to worry about healthcare through it all, but millions in the US are not nearly so fortunate.
So for us it comes down to dumb luck, and we're hardly alone. Once you've applied for jobs, taken advantage of every available government aid program, researched and applied for scholarships and still nothing happens, it ultimately comes down to dumb luck. Winning the lottery or having a good day at the local casino or finding a wad of bills someone accidentally dropped on the sidewalk on their way to the bank. Or maybe you just bump into some incredibly generous soul willing to pay a truly decent wage in exchange for some yard work or something. Whatever. But planning and effort really have nothing to do with it. The fact you've done everything you've been advised to do doesn't really matter. Attempting to improve your life, an act praised by politicians and preachers alike, it turns out has odds increasingly resembling those found at a slot machine in your local gambling establishment. It doesn't have to, of course, but collectively we've all put up with it so far so here we are.
So are we going to make it Canada? Probably not. We probably can't make it in the US either. In two wealthy societies with so much work that needs to be done - infrastructure maintenance and replacement backlogs now totaling in the trillions of dollars, research opportunities galore, environmental restoration work desperately needing to be done - we are actually expected to believe there is no work available and to accept funding cuts in the interest of "shared sacrifice". In a culture that praises education we force students to graduate under the burden of staggering debt and allow tuition and fees to grow significantly faster than inflation year after year. Meanwhile, our politicians run on themes of hope while embracing tax cuts for the wealthy and spending cuts for the rest of us. Or worse, they run away from science, label the educated "elite", and call any suggestion the wealthy pay a bit more "class warfare". These will be our choices as long as we continue to tolerate them.
So if we make it here or anywhere else it will be as much or more due to dumb luck than any effort we exert. We've exerted plenty, to the point of giving it all we can in every way imaginable. Like a growing list of millions in the industrialized world and billions elsewhere, it comes down to dumb luck as our leaders embrace what amounts to the modern equivalent of Social Darwinism. But as many dictators in North Africa and the Middle East are currently learning, luck is a double edged sword. Eventually, if rhetoric and reality continue to diverge, our leaders' luck will run out as well. If Chris and I and millions more in our shoes are lucky, that day will be soon.